Friday, May 20, 2016

The Lucifer Effect: Deindividuation

In Chapter 13 of the Lucifer Effect, Zimbardo discusses the topic of deindividuation.  I found it interesting that as soon as a person becomes anonymous, they are so much more likely to commit crimes they never would have if they were identifiable.  This is seen originally in the Stanford Prison experiment, when the guards' eyes (and identities) were concealed by reflective sunglasses.  Zimbardo drew the conclusion from their actions that anything that makes a person feel or seem anonymous decreases their sense of personal accountability.  Without holding themselves accountable for their actions, they are more likely to commit evil actions.  And, when put into a situation where it is socially acceptable to be violent or rude to others, people are ready to do things they never would have normally.

In daily life, these conclusions can also be seen.  When people treat you as just a person rather than a unique individual, a feeling of anonymity is achieved.  In a study where some college students were treated kindly and some treated as "guinea pigs", those who felt anonymous were more likely to steal from the professor when left alone in his office.  The lack of identifiability can result in "evil" behaviour a person would not likely engage in normally.

Psychology 2016

With this last post I want to conclude my experience on taking Psychology this semester. I think it has been a great opportunity for me to understand people's behaviors. Now that I learned a lot of scenarios where social influence can manage my behaviors (diffusion of responsibility), I feel more conscious of my decision-making. My favorite unit was by far "The transformations of Human Character". It amazes me how good people can end up showing their "evil side", like the guards of The Stanford Prison Experiment.
This class has helped me a lot to avoid social influence and take decisions by myself. Are you satisfied with what we learned in this class? Which was your favorite chapter? Would you like to learn something else about psychology before the year ends? Share your thoughts and maybe we can let Mr. Steward know!

Diffusion of responsibilty

In this blog I wanted to talk about Latane and Darley’s experiment of diffusion of responsibility. This last couple weeks I have been paying attention and I realized that this human behavior is really common in our society. Diffusion of responsibility is a social-psychological phenomenon by which a person is less likely to take responsibility for action when others are in present. The clearest example I saw about this circumstance was I while ago, during spring break.  I was taking a break from my ski day. I could see the entire slope from the bench which I was sitting. A man probably about 20 years old was going down with his snowboard really fast. He seemed to handle it pretty well, but suddenly he tripped on something and fell down in a rough way. He looked like he was in pain. Me and my friends saw the action perfectly and were worried about him, but it seemed like we were the only ones who cared. The people that were going down the same slope just looked at him and continued skiing like if nothing happened. After about 5 minutes the guy was still on the ground. Finally, a woman stopped and called the ski patrol. I was really surprised; Why didn’t anyone else stop before? I’m sure it was not because no one cared about him. It was just a matter of diffusion of responsibility. Responsibility is diffused when there are other people that could help. Everyone thought that someone else would help him, but because of that no one actually did. I was kind of upset after what happened and started thinking that everyone had been selfish. So, based on this last case, could diffusion of responsibility be compared to the human’s ego-centrism or is it just a matter of social influence?







Stereotypes as an Identity

In order for racism to not exist anymore, stereotypes have to be forgotten. So why is it so difficult to get rid of strongly ingrained racial stereotypes? Often I notice people can strongly believe in these stereotypes, and can often express them too, but people start to adhere to them. It seems to me that stereotypes are false, but are slowly becoming true again because people hear it constantly and start to subconsciously act in identical ways, almost like the 3rd graders who started to perform badly if they felt they were inferior - although the study was carried out in an odd way. I don't believe in stereotypes but hearing them constantly, whether as a joke or as an insult, definitely makes me feel as if adhering to it is the easy way to go.

Denying the Obvious

How can someone blatantly deny something they know is true? Do they maybe believe that if they hold their ground on the topic their opposition will change the subject or accept their view as correct? It amazes me how many people can simply stand there and say no, when the question is something simple like "Is 2+2=4?" What could possibly be going through their heads to the point where they will actually say that the sun orbits the earth, or god forbid they say the earth is flat. Is it just maybe they get overwhelmed and find it easier to stand their ground?

Scapegoating Races

Nowadays, there is a lot of controversy in the media talking about racism and privilege, specifically white privilege. You can actually meet people who are totally convinced white privilege is the cause of all their problems, and can become a part of exclusive groups who believe the same. I understand ending white privilege and stuff like that, but using all white people as scapegoats for personal problems is not a healthy way to approach a situation. I think it has turned into more of a hobby nowadays, because it is so common for so many people.

Projecting Anger

I find it interesting hearing about people projecting their anger and emotions towards someone, when they were given it by someone else. I can understand being frustrated, but why hurt someone else when you can hurt the main cause of your distress and anger? Personally, if someone wrongs me I just remember that they wronged me, and exact revenge either at the time or much later. I can understand projection but I don't see how it can become sustained projection, rather than just an outburst.

Anonymity in Stanford Prison Experiment

The guards in the Stanford Prison Experiment did things that got worse and worse as the experiment went on, but I cannot determine if the cause for all of these terrible things is mainly due to the fact that they could remain completely anonymous when doing these crimes by wearing their sunglasses, or just because what they were doing they perceived as being right, because they had no reference point for how prison guards were supposed to act. I think it is mainly due to the fact that this is an isolated experiment, and the guards thought they were doing the right thing, much like the Japanese in the Rape of Nanking. Thoughts?

Serial Killers

I found it interesting that while studying serial killers and psychopaths, they all blamed someone else. Not a single one of them ever managed to take responsibility for their crimes. I found this odd, because I remember learning about how they feel good when killing people, so it surprises me that they would not take the credit when offered, even when they knew they would be in prison for the rest of their life. Was it a spur of the moment thing for them to take credit? Or did they actually believe that being taunted by a girl in the 4th grade was the reason they had murdered and raped 50 women?

Suicide

After reading about the suicide clusters at Palo Alto, it got me thinking. Did the positive response by the students at Palo Alto make people realize that having all those students focused on them would finally provide them with the attention they needed? Do you think some students may have ended their lives AFTER the initial suicides because they wanted the same attention? I think it would make sense for lonely kids who seek attention to take their own lives in the face of such a positive response. Thoughts?

The Lucifer Effect: Dehumanization


While reading about dehumanization in “The Lucifer Effect,” I began questioning why history always seems to repeat itself. In the dehumanization section there were various examples of how people severely mistreated others and saw them as objects rather than people. Time and time again humans have seen the effects of dehumanization, however it seems like there is always some form of it existing in society. Nations criticize other nations for their history, but the truth is that every society has either been dehumanized or has dehumanized another group. It is hard for me to grasp why dehumanization keeps occurring; I’d like to believe that people are generally good, however it is hard to believe that when there is always a group of people who feel superior, which is exactly what fuels discrimination, prejudice and inequality in all societies. I do not think there is a viable solution to prevent dehumanization from reappearing, however I think that reflecting about our own prejudices and biases can contribute to a better future for humanity.  

Good People Still Commit Crimes

In class Mr. Stewart was saying how people who believe that they are good are more susceptible to doing bad things, because ultimately they believe they have good values and good judgement, making them feel less guilt or culpability when committing an action that is considered wrong. This idea really intrigued me, because well I do believe I am a good person and I would never expect to do something I morally disagree with, so consequently I began questioning how that could be possible. Throughout history, humanity has experienced the malice of people, most of the time people who seem normal. Psychopaths make up only 1% of society, however there have been multiple times in history where countless groups of people have committed atrocious acts, therefore there is something else that drives what are seemingly ordinary people to commit acts of low moral standards. I think this idea has a lot to do with the theory of obedience to authority; through Milgrim’s experiment this theory is proven. People who have an overall morally correct judgement still commit crimes, especially when under pressure from an authority, this is because it is human nature, or instinct, to be obedient to those who are superior or those who are considered of higher power.

Being Valedictorian Doesn’t Always Equal Happiness


A few weeks ago when we were reading through the “The Silicon Valley Suicides” article, there was a particular idea in the article that left me confused and in disbelief; the article stated that a lot of these parents which pressured their children into being the top of their class, compromised the happiness of their children. Immediately what came to my mind was that that was ridiculous, I could not believe that parents would not value their child’s happiness enough to even begin empathizing for them. It makes me really sad to know that numerous parents exist who are like that, especially in this area. Personally, I do feel pressure from my parents to do well in school, but nothing overwhelming, they’ve always told me to put my happiness first. These parents do not understand that the pressure they put on their kids has a huge impact on how they view themselves and their goals. I would think that as a parent you would want the best for your child, however that does not only mean having your child be the best in school, but that also comes with emotional health. I do not see much point in life when you are unhappy. I understand that these parents worry for the future of their children, however they really need to step back and reflect how their actions affect their kids’ decisions, because most of the time these students are trying to conform to their parents standards, despite feeling completely overwhelmed.

Throwback to Cognitive Dissonance Theory

1959 experiment, psychologist Leon Festinger asked participants to preform a series of dull tasks, like turning pegs in a wooden knob, for an hour. They were then paid either $1 or $20 to tell a "waiting participant" (aka a researcher) that the task was very interesting. Those who were paid $1 to lie rated the tasks as more enjoyable than those who were paid $20. Those who were paid more felt that they had sufficient justification for having preformed the rate task for an hour, but those who were only paid $1 felt the need to justify the time spent (and reduce the level of dissonance between their beliefs and their behavior) by saying that the activity was fun. We commonly tell ourselves lies to make the world appear a more reasonable place.

For example, when my friends and I were talking about work and how much we get pain an hour, I didn't feel the need to contribute as much input or information because I was making the most an hour out of all my friends (not to sound snobby). Almost all of my friends make $10 an hour, but since I get paid $13 an hour (bare with me) I felt justified for all the work I had to do for that one hour. While my friends explain how laid back and chill it is to not have to do much for $10 an hour.

Examples / experiences? Thought?

http://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html

Robbers Cave Experiment

Muzafer Sherif (Turkish-American social psychologist) took two groups of 11 boys (all age 11) to Robbers Cave State Park in Oklahoma for "summer camp." The groups (named the "Eagles" and the "Rattles") spent a week apart, having fun together and bonding, with no knowledge of the existence of the other group. When the two groups finally got together, the boys started calling each other names, and when they started competing in various games, more conflicts began and eventually the groups refused to eat together. In the next phase of the research, Sherif designed experiments to try to balance the boys by having them enjoy leisure activities together (which was not successful) and then having them solve a problem together, which finally eased the conflict.

This explains many social behaviors we see today, mainly in school. Children come from all sorts of different backgrounds, which illustrates why they have a difficult time adjusting at a younger age because they don't try to relate to those who don't have the same similarities / interests. Thinking back to my elementary and middle school days, I can remember witnessing this a few times. Experiences? Thoughts?

http://www.age-of-the-sage.org/psychology/social/sherif_robbers_cave_experiment.html

The Cookie Experiment, 2003

A 2003 study put students into groups of three to write a short paper together. Two students were instructed to write the paper, while the other was told to evaluate the paper and determine how much each student would be paid. In the middle of their work, a researcher brought in a plate of five cookies. Although generally the last cookie was never eaten, the "boss" almost always ate the fourth cookie. 

Based on the experiment, researchers gathered that when people are given power in scientific experiments, they are more likely to make risky choices and gambles, to make offers into negotiations, and to speak their mind about their needs. 

I never really thought about the psychology behind eating a cookie, but it does make sense. There is something about having a simple job title that, in a weird way, makes you feel powerful and significant. Can anyone think of an example of this type of human behavior?

The Shock Experiment

A famous 1961 study by Yale psychologist Stanley Milgram tested how far people would go to obey authority figure when asked to harm others, and the intense internal conflict between personal morals and the obligation to obey authority figures. Milgram tested a pair of participants, one deemed the "teacher" and the other deemed the "learner." The teacher was instructed to administer electric shocks to the learner (who was supposedly sitting in another room, but in reality was not being shocked) each time they got questions wrong. He instead played recordings which made it sound like the learner was in pain, and if the "teacher" subject expressed a desire to stop, the experimenter prodded him to go on. During the first experiment, 65% of the participants administered a painful although many were uncomfortable about doing so.

Does this experiment lean more towards blind obedience to authority? Or more towards conflicting moral tendencies that lie within? Any other additional thoughts on this experiment.

http://www.simplypsychology.org/milgram.html




Community vs Competition


I’ve been working with a few other marching band members recently regarding a presentation aimed towards incoming freshman. Our goal is to recruit as many new people as possible, but the main focus of our speech has brought up an interesting debate within our group: is it more important to focus on community or competition? While my vote was for community, others did not have the same ideas as I did. They believed that in order to motivate the freshman, we needed to show that we were a high-accomplishing and very intense community. We did have a very successful previous season, but that is not who we are at the heart of it. Anyone is welcome in our community, and that should be the main motivator for what we have to offer. 

This doesn’t just apply to band- I’ve seen many instances where people value the game over the players, and I am often on the other side of the discussion. However, for a team to be truly successful, it is necessary to have a balance, and to make sure that everyone is aware of that balance.

Change Blindness

In 1998, researchers from Harvard and Kentucky State University targeted pedestrians on a college campus to determine how much people notice about their immediate environment. In the experiment, an actor came up to a pedestrian and asked for directions. While the pedestrian was giving the directions, two men carrying a large wooden door walked between the actor and the pedestrian, completely blocking their view of each other for several seconds. During that time, the actor was replaced by another actor, one of the different height and build, and with a different outfit, haircut and voice. A full half of the participants didn't notice the substitution.

This experiment was one of the first to illustrate the occurrence of "change blindness," which shows just how selective we are about what we take in from any given visual scene and it seems that we rely on memory and patterns significantly more than we might think. Agree or disagree?

https://public.wsu.edu/~fournier/Teaching/psych198/simons&levin1998.pdf

Thursday, May 19, 2016

Are the Symptoms of OCD Usually Exaggerated?

A few weeks back, Mr. Stewart gave a lecture on psychological disorders and some therapies that can be used to treat them.  He also gave us a link to the page for the National Insititute of Mental Health.  I have been interested in OCD since reading this article and because of how often it shows up in the media and everyday life.  This is one of those terms, like crazy or ADHD that is tossed around and used casually regardless of whether or not a person is affected by it or not.  On the NIMH website, it says that OCD is a disorder in which a person affected has "uncontrollable, reoccuring thoughts and behaviors that he or she feels the urge to repeat over and over."  Ever since the beginning of this school year, I have been experiencing minor symptoms of this disorder, but I thought nothing of it because I thought that it was normal for everyone to experience symptoms that are out of the ordinary every once in a while.  But some of these practices have gotten to the point where they are interrupting my daily life.  For example, I'll be reading a book and I'll know that I have already read the first section of a page, but I have to go back and read it just be sure.  Also, when I lock my car, I have to make sure that I hear it beep twice to make sure that it is locked, and I am often paranoid of it being unlocked even if I know that I locked it.  I have to read and reread assignments multiple times because I'm not quite sure if I got it the first time around even if I am positive that I did.  I experience many other little compulsions that I have to carry out everyday.  Also, as per the symptoms, I have certain actions that I repeat everyday (i.e. whistling the same song all day, unnecessarily clearing my throat, etc.)  Also, I am generally a person who likes things to be neat and tidy.  I'm not looking for any medical help; I just want people to give their opinions based on what we have learned this year (psychological terms, using the NIMH website, etc).  What I'm wondering is this: Are these actual symptoms or is it just me being overly paranoid?  Could stress be a factor?  Does anyone have any other general thoughts on OCD?  On mental illness?