Friday, May 6, 2016
Can Colleges Really Judge Well Based on Numbers?
This is kind of going back to our discussion about the SAT a few months back, but I feel is applicable now that we're talking about pressure from school in the suicide article. In the documentary from a few months ago, it was revealed that college admissions mostly take into consideration test scores and GPA when accepting students. We already talked about test scores not being fair because of the availability of different test preparation resources that are available to some high school students and aren't available to others. But what about GPA? This is something that varies completely from school to school. Even if two students at different schools take the same class, they may experience a difference in the rigor of the course, how lenient their teacher is with grading, the work load, and many other factors. In other words, when one student gets an A in one class at one school it likely doesn't mean the same thing at another school. Even between Mountain View and Los Altos high schools there are differences in classes that I and my friends are both taking. And these two schools are in the same district! Because grading is a very subjective process, I don't think that colleges should be allowed to consider GPA and should put more of a stress on their essays and extracurriculars when considering future students. Looking at a person for who they are rather than what test scores they are made up of will better reflect how they will fare in college courses and what kind of person that they will develop into. Personally, I think that this information is much more helpful and good to know about a future student for college admissions. What do others think?
Cameron Lee's Suicide
Cameron Lee is one of many victims of suicide in Gunn High School. What hit me about this student is the question: Why did he commit suicide? Some people will say that usually the kids who commit suicide are the ones who are considered to be the "outcasts" in school, and are unsuccessful. Cameron was a high achieving student, and was very sociable from what people have reported in the article. If this was the case, then what provoked him to kill himself? Shouldn't he have been content with his life if he had all these available to him?
Depression is a mental illness that ignores social status. Cameron could have been affected by this while he was alive, which would explain why he "never seemed to sleep". Sleep deprivation is linked to depression, which could suggest that he was suffering from this and lied to his friends about his reasons for being awake so late.
It is said that Cameron's reasons for committing suicide were unclear, but it was unrelated to school, family, or friends. If so, then what could his real reason be? Why do you think Cameron left a note like this instead of explaining why he killed himself?
Depression is a mental illness that ignores social status. Cameron could have been affected by this while he was alive, which would explain why he "never seemed to sleep". Sleep deprivation is linked to depression, which could suggest that he was suffering from this and lied to his friends about his reasons for being awake so late.
It is said that Cameron's reasons for committing suicide were unclear, but it was unrelated to school, family, or friends. If so, then what could his real reason be? Why do you think Cameron left a note like this instead of explaining why he killed himself?
Sleepless in America
Wednesday, I was watching the news as I was eating breakfast, and I saw this one story that was particularly interesting. Here is the link to an article and the TV clip (which is ironically named "Wake-up Call for Insomniacs"): http://www.today.com/health/insomnia-try-therapy-pills-new-guidelines-say-t90136.
It talked about something that is pretty common in the United States: chronic insomnia. According to their sources, between 6 and 10 percent of American adults have insomnia so bad that it can be classified as a clinical disorder. Many of these affected adults are quick to pop a pill to get the rest that they so desperately want but have trouble finding. But the story said that this is not the right way to go about overcoming insomnia. Instead, it said that there is a promising future in cognitive behavioral therapy to help insomniacs get to sleep and stay asleep. According to the presentation from class on these therapies, the definition should be: a therapy that both modifies behavior and trains a person's mind to think a certain way. Based on Mayoclinic's definition of cognitive behavioral therapy, I was correct in assuming that it is a combination of cognitive and behavioral therapy. It is also a therapy that is limited to a certain number of sessions and helps people realize their negative mindset and how to overcome it. If you watch the video, it does end up explaining cognitive behavioral therapy as a structured process that involves three steps: addressing and changing negative thoughts that might interrupt normal sleep, trying to change behaviors that interrupt sleep and maintaining a normal sleep pattern, and enforcing healthy sleep practices. Now, when I heard this, I remember thinking to myself that this is nothing new. Addressing the problem at its heart generally is better than dousing it with medication. But then I realized, maybe people might be reluctant to join the therapy because they are still stuck in the mindset that they don't want to admit that they have something wrong with them. The pills or medication is something that has grown normal for people having sleeping difficulties. I think it is an example of normative influence and also, possibly, learned helplessness. This is very similar to the situation with the article about suicide we were reading in class. In that case, the children are complaining about the school system being too stressful, but they don't do anything to get out of the school system or seek alternative schooling. It's all they've known and all they think can help them to succeed later in life. They don't want to take a risk even if the stress level is so large. It's a similar issue here. On the other hand, it could just be the rigor of the therapy: 6-8 weeks of structure involving no naps and basically forcing oneself into sleep-deprivation. The video promises positive results after the sleep-deprivation. But in the end, I'm skeptical that people will want to stick with the therapy rather than get the instant result they want from pills (even with the health issues associated with prolonged use). Do others agree? Do you think that this type of therapy would work? Or do you think another type would work better? Any other thoughts?
It talked about something that is pretty common in the United States: chronic insomnia. According to their sources, between 6 and 10 percent of American adults have insomnia so bad that it can be classified as a clinical disorder. Many of these affected adults are quick to pop a pill to get the rest that they so desperately want but have trouble finding. But the story said that this is not the right way to go about overcoming insomnia. Instead, it said that there is a promising future in cognitive behavioral therapy to help insomniacs get to sleep and stay asleep. According to the presentation from class on these therapies, the definition should be: a therapy that both modifies behavior and trains a person's mind to think a certain way. Based on Mayoclinic's definition of cognitive behavioral therapy, I was correct in assuming that it is a combination of cognitive and behavioral therapy. It is also a therapy that is limited to a certain number of sessions and helps people realize their negative mindset and how to overcome it. If you watch the video, it does end up explaining cognitive behavioral therapy as a structured process that involves three steps: addressing and changing negative thoughts that might interrupt normal sleep, trying to change behaviors that interrupt sleep and maintaining a normal sleep pattern, and enforcing healthy sleep practices. Now, when I heard this, I remember thinking to myself that this is nothing new. Addressing the problem at its heart generally is better than dousing it with medication. But then I realized, maybe people might be reluctant to join the therapy because they are still stuck in the mindset that they don't want to admit that they have something wrong with them. The pills or medication is something that has grown normal for people having sleeping difficulties. I think it is an example of normative influence and also, possibly, learned helplessness. This is very similar to the situation with the article about suicide we were reading in class. In that case, the children are complaining about the school system being too stressful, but they don't do anything to get out of the school system or seek alternative schooling. It's all they've known and all they think can help them to succeed later in life. They don't want to take a risk even if the stress level is so large. It's a similar issue here. On the other hand, it could just be the rigor of the therapy: 6-8 weeks of structure involving no naps and basically forcing oneself into sleep-deprivation. The video promises positive results after the sleep-deprivation. But in the end, I'm skeptical that people will want to stick with the therapy rather than get the instant result they want from pills (even with the health issues associated with prolonged use). Do others agree? Do you think that this type of therapy would work? Or do you think another type would work better? Any other thoughts?
Education System
In this higher class area, we have seen that our schools are just as dysfunctional as those in poverty. I, just like many others, believe there are a lot of things that could be better with our education system, like better preparation for the situations we will face as adults as well as less homework. But if we feel that the school system is so flawed, why do we still participate in it? It goes along with the truth that we have been taught - by our parents, peers, teachers, etc - that there is only one path to be successful in life, and this is the most important step of that process. And while it's true that school does not have to be insanely stressful and overwhelming due to choosing your classes, students are extremely pressured to "challenge themselves" which can be a good thing, but not to the extent that we in our high-expectations society expect a challenge to be. Students find it nearly impossible to balance school with all of the aspects of their life, like their social life, family, their hobbies/passions, and the extracurriculars they have signed up for just for the sake of "success." So, I believe it is not actually the school system itself that causes stress, but the pressure to follow the supposed single path to success that causes students to turn school and other things into stressors by overwhelming themselves.
What do you think?
What do you think?
Thursday, May 5, 2016
Stars can't shine without darkness
Today I would like to talk about the article on the Suicide Clusters at Palo Alto High Schools. Some people are surprised about the higher amounts of distress and pressure that kids suffer from in this area. While reading the article, I realized that a lot of the main aspects are also noticeable in Barcelona (where I’m from). People may think “How can they be stressed when they have everything they need? It does not make sense! They provide them everything they could ask for, so why should they be upset?”. The facts of having a very good environment and being surrounded by wealthy people creates a very high standard of living. Furthermore, knowing that your parents and your family succeeded automatically makes you want to succeed too. Being raised around people who achieved their goals and earned a decent amount of money makes you think that their situation is usual. However when you get to high school you realize that life is not all about shining stars. On the contrary, now you have to work hard to achieve your “social status requirements”. This is when pressure comes into play. The kids are so used to have everything they want that when they have to work hard to continue having them they find themselves overwhelmed. Some of them get stuck on the situation and identify themselves as failure. They think they are not obtaining what their social status requires, although they are probably in a better position than kids with lower academic expectations.
So, in response to those people who don’t understand why sometimes wealthy kids can also be upset and distressed: Sometimes as better is your social status, higher are your expectations. Everyone suffers from some type of pressure and mostly during adolescence, because it’s when you start depending on yourself. But although the pressure, the stress and the pain something can cause, it does not mean that you have “failed” and even less that you have to kill yourself, like those kids in the Silicon Valley. As the quote says: “Stars can’t shine without darkness”, right?
Pressure from Parents in School
Today Mr. Stewart asked the class if they have ever been pressured by their parent’s to be a certain way and if they thought if their parents knew that they were pressuring them this much. He then asked if anyone felt like “Hell yeah I’m going to put pressure on my kid, have you seen the kids who don’t get pressured from their parents?!” and that made me think.
Growing up, I was never really pressured by my grandma, who raised me, because all I knew was that I didn’t want to be like my mom and I wanted to be in a way better than her. I then started to think about how my kids aren’t going to have that bad example in their lives since I’m an only child and didn’t make the mistakes my mom made, they’re not going to have a personal connection with someone who messed up for them. I mean, yeah, I’m going to be able to tell them all of the bad things I did and why I didn’t do the things my mom did, but what if they think “Well you did blank and you ended up in a good position in life, so if I do blank I’ll be able to get by too”?
Monday, May 2, 2016
Suicide
Today we learned about many common misconceptions regarding suicide. One common myth is that people who talk about committing suicide will not actually do it. Truthfully, when someone speaks about death or killing themselves, it could very likely be a cry for help, and should always be taken seriously. Another common misconception is that someone who tries to commit suicide but fails will not make any other attempts. This is false because if someone tries to take their life, even though they were unsuccessful, the idea of suicide still exists in their mind.
It is also important to be aware and watch for any warning signs a suicidal person may show. Some include an increase in the use of drugs or alcohol, talking about death or killing oneself, talking about feeling hopeless or trapped, and many other things. If someone shows any signs of being suicidal, it is extremely important to help in any way. Many things can be done to help such as seeking out a doctor or a mental health professional, or even just talking to the person to show that you care about them and want them in your life.
What are your thoughts on this topic?
It is also important to be aware and watch for any warning signs a suicidal person may show. Some include an increase in the use of drugs or alcohol, talking about death or killing oneself, talking about feeling hopeless or trapped, and many other things. If someone shows any signs of being suicidal, it is extremely important to help in any way. Many things can be done to help such as seeking out a doctor or a mental health professional, or even just talking to the person to show that you care about them and want them in your life.
What are your thoughts on this topic?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)