Friday, May 13, 2016

Jane Elliott's Experiment

In The Lucifer Effect, we read about an Iowa schoolteacher who taught her third-grade students, who had never experienced racism, what it feels like to be a minority and to be a victim of discrimination. In addition, some students learned what it feels like to be "superior" for superficial reasons. She divided her class based upon eye color, with the blue-eyed students being "superior" and the brown-eyed students being "inferior. The next day, she switched the two categories. She found that the students who were "inferior" quickly developed low self-esteem and began to see themselves in a negative light; they also became victimized by the "superior" group of children.

I looked into this experiment, and read about a documentary created about it called A Class Divided. The experiment took place the day after Martin Luther King, Jr.'s death, and Jane Elliott was inspired by this event to teach her students about racism and prejudice. The documentary follows the children from the experiment into their adulthood. Apparently, in the documentary, all of students felt that it was wrong to place prejudice upon others for superficial reasons and to exhibit racism. In addition, they all said that the experiment changed their lives profoundly.

I infer that this made the students more accepting of others' differences, given how they all experienced a form of prejudice in the classroom experiment. Given that third-graders are very impressionable, they probably very quickly began to believe that they actually were "superior" or "inferior." Then, I started to wonder how the same experiment would work with older students or adults, who are less impressionable than young children. Would it have the same profound effects? Would it teach its participants about how it feels to be unfairly judged, and would it change their perspectives? Thoughts?

Thursday, May 12, 2016

Intervention: Laney

The most relevant concept is for Laney is learned helplessness because it is what keeps her addiction going. Her family also shows learned helplessness by not helping her or being around her because they believe there is no use in trying to make her change. Laney believes that she can't turn her life around, so she continues her alcoholic tendencies instead. If her family tried to help, and she was willing to help herself, she could overcome her issues with alcoholism. Another relevant concept is illusory correlation because Laney makes a connection between her relationship with her ex-husband and her relationship with her stepfather. Even though they are not alike, Laney sees similar tendencies between the two. This caused her to push her husband away, and ultimately lead to their divorce. What are your thoughts about Laney?

Gunn Suicides

We recently learned about the suicide clusters that occurred at Gunn high school. These suicides caused some questions to arise, one of them being, what is it about Palo Alto that causes these suicides? The article we read by The Atlantic suggested that parental pressure is a contributing factor to the depression and suicide rate. While I agree with this, I also believe that self-pressure plays a huge role. Since we live in a very successful area, many students feel as if they must accomplish as much or even more than their parents have. This causes students to take many advanced courses, which leads to heavy workloads, and lots of stress. What are your thoughts on this topic?

The "missing child" experiment


Last night I watched a video about a social experiment and it certainly called my attention. The experiment was called “the missing child”. After watching the video I did some research and I noticed that a lot of people had tried it before. The idea of the experiment was to observe how often people fail to notice their surroundings and, when they don’t, what is their fear to get involved in the situation. The experimenters hanged posters with information and a picture of a “missing child” on all the trees in a park. Some people stopped to read the poster while others didn’t look at all.  At first, no one noticed that the “missing child” was sitting in one of the benches in the park. After a few hours they moved the child next to one of the posters so he could be easily seen. Some people recognized him but they didn’t say anything, they didn’t get involved. They just stared at him for a few seconds and continued walking. I realized that this human behavior could be a consequence of the bystander effect. This social phenomenon happens when individuals do not offer any means of help to a victim when other people are present. People don’t like to get involved in a potentially uncomfortable situation specially if no one else seems to be doing so. What do you guys think about the results of this experiment? Did they surprise you?     

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Wealth = Expectations

One of the main things I took away from the article on the Gunn suicides was the expectations that come with wealth.  It was mentioned that when a child's parents have done everything-- gone to an amazing university, held an amazing job, maintained a family, and secured a spot for their child in a place where they are exposed to so many opportunities, the child feels like they need to achieve that and more.  This idea only appears in elite families, and brings many responsibilities and expectations of the child to essentially uphold the family name/honour.  Most of the time, I don't think this is something that is ever verbalized, but the students definitely feel it.  My parents have never told me that I need to do x, y, and z, but there has always been a push to take advantage of my situation and go above and beyond the average.  Whether that's shown in the APs they encourage me to take, or the planning of my future they want me to start, the point is that there has always been an expectation that I will use the resources and chances I have that they didn't and become more successful in my life than them.  I think this expectation is what weighs on students in our area and brings these negative outcomes like stress, suicide, depression, etc.

Tuesday, May 10, 2016

Gunn Suicide Article

After talking about the "suicide clusters" at Gunn and Palo Alto High School, many view points that we mentioned during class made me think about what other people are really going through when it comes to school. Before reading this article, I would just go with the accusation that the homework load, tests, and quizzes was the main stress factor that contributed to the suicides. When we read about Cameron's situation, he was not your stereotypical antisocial student who would be contemplating suicide. Cameron "was a great student, all A's. He didn't really worry about school, it came easy for him," along with his "good time management." As we discussed what the possible causes of this huge issue could be, I learned a number of factors that could contribute to this essential issue. I do realize that there is no single answer that gives everyone a reasonable solution, but there are some aspects of school that can contribute to the student's stress in our overall area. Which of the possibilities mentioned in the article do you think is the most inflicted on students?

Sunday, May 8, 2016

School and Stress

   After our in-class lesson, I decided to do a little more research on schools and stress. According to this article, the rate of depression is four times higher in people who do three or more hours of homework. While the article talks about how parents often compound this stress by pushing their students to succeed in school, it also notes that this is certainty not the only cause of stress. In class, we briefly talked about how the school environment greatly builds stress in students. We talked about the pressure to take high-level courses and do extra-curricular activities in class, but I think there is more to the issue. A number of sophomores that I know took MEHAP because they didn't know what they were getting into, and have been very stressed out these past two weeks, as well as somewhat stressed out for the entire year because of the course load. If schools had a way for students to judge and know about homework load other than by asking upperclassmen, a huge amount of this stress could be eliminated, resulting in a healthier and happier school. While there is no perfect solution, what do you guys think could help solve this issue of high stress in school?