In the Luicifer Effect readings, we learned about a scenario where an elementary school teacher convinced her students that blue-eyed children were better than brown eyed ones, leading to a huge change in behavior, including name-calling and a new divide in academic results between brown and blue-eyed kids. After this, she reversed the roles, telling the students that brown-eyed people were actually superior. After reading this section, I began to wonder: to what extent does age matter in these experiments? From the readings, it seemed that the older people had to be gently prodded more to get to a state of furor, with the college students being asked a series of questions with increasing severity. The high schoolers also had to be given a series on increasing difficulty of instructions to reach their state of frenzy, whereas the elementary schoolers only had to be told a few "facts" about eye color to become hateful. Furthermore, I did some further research and stumbled on this (https://books.google.com/books?id=WXGUxpv9aSwC&lpg=PP1&pg=PA270#v=onepage&q&f=false) online textbook, which says that, in the Milgrim experiments, the old and young subjects had negligible differences in obedience to women. However, when instructed by a man, the younger people were much more obedient, and the older subjects were significantly more disobedient than when asked by a woman. Although this is beyond the material that we have covered in class, and I was unable to find much information on the topic, I can theorize that the subjects of this one of Milgrim's test, who were all men, subconsciously saw an older man as an almost fatherly figure, accepting his authority in the experiment, while they saw younger men as challengers and rejected their instruction. This would also explain why, when the instructor was a woman, the obedience was roughly baseline, as this subconscious paternal vs challenger was never put into play. What are your guys' thoughts on what caused this discrepancy in obedience between people who were asked by women and men, as well as the obedience change between the ages.
Tuesday, May 17, 2016
The Lucifer Effect: Halloween Experiment
In the Halloween Experiment explained in Chapter 13 of the Lucifer Effect, kids were given games to play against each other at a Halloween party. At first, the kids played without costumes. However, in the second phase, the students wore costumes, keeping their identities secret from their peers. This second phase resulted in an increase of aggression while playing. Then for the third phase, the students took off the costumes and continued to play. This third phase showed that there was no carryover of the aggressive behavior displayed in phase two. These results show the power of anonymity. I also believe this is similar to diffusion of responsibility. Since the children are in costume and no one knows who they are, they feel less responsible for their actions. This causes them to do things uncharacteristic to their normal behavior. What are your thoughts on this experiment?
The Lucifer Effect: Milgram's Shock Experiment
In a similar experiment to the original shock experiment, Milgram conducted one that included puppies and student volunteers conditioning the puppy's behavior using electric shocks. The students could clearly see that the puppy was in distress, and some of the females even cried during the experiment. However, seeing that did not stop them from continuing as 54% of the men went all the way to 450 volts, and a shocking 100% of female students went to 450 volts despite their obvious discomfort. While it may seem like these participants are terrible people, they really are just "normal" people with no psychopathic characteristics. Their blind obedience was towards the college professor that ordered them to do such actions. This experiment further proves Zimbardo's theory that "it is difficult for people to appreciate fully the power of situational forces acting on individual behavior when they are viewed outside the behavioral context." Do you agree or disagree?
Monday, May 16, 2016
The Lucifer Effect: The Palo Alto "Holocaust"
In my opinion, the Palo Alto "Holocaust" was one of the most frightening experiments described in The Lucifer Effect. It happened so close to us, and with students generally regarded as smart and intelligent. The students adopted the Nazi-esque rules so quickly that it is scary to think what someone with a little authority could do when people so easily bend to their will. In the experiment, strict classroom rules were enforced to "level the playing field" for all students. Intelligent and well-worded students no longer had the upper hand in class discussion, and were overtaken by physical and less verbal students. An "in-group" was formed, and the brightest students were ridiculed and outcasted. What was most surprising to me was how quickly students conformed to the new standards, and how quick they were to turn on their classmates. The students seemed to have completely forgotten their personal beliefs and morals and instead put their complete faith/trust in an authoritative figure's hands. Do you think it would be possible for something similar to happen at Los Altos High?
The Lucifer Effect: Blind Obedience
In Chapter 12 of The Lucifer Effect, Zimbardo describes the test in which a team of doctors and nurses tested obedience in their authority system. They did so by having an anonymous "physician" call each of the twenty-two nurses and tell her to give medication to the patient so that it would be in effect by the time he reached the hospital. The medication was 20 mg of Astrogen although on the bottle, it warned that 10+ mL was the max dosage. The results were terrifying: all but one of the nurses obediently complied. After further investigation, a survey revealed that 46% of nurses "reported that they could recall a time when they had in fact 'carried out a physician's order that you felt could have had harmful consequences to the patient.'"They did so because they felt less responsibility on themselves than on the physician if something went wrong. This is really problematic in hospitals which contain many life-or-death situations. As stated in the chapter, "Thousands of hospitalized patients die needlessly each year due to a variety of staff mistakes..." some which can be attributed to situations similar to the ones demonstrated in the experiment.
Sunday, May 15, 2016
Self-Perception Through Sketches
Last week, forensic sketch artist Gil Zamora visited my youth group to talk about self-confidence and how people see themselves. Some of you may have seen this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrHoDJinMQI) sponsored by Dove, in which he draws several women by their own descriptions and then by another person's description. In all of the sketches, the sketch drawn by the person describing themselves always highlights their physical flaws that they see in themselves. The sketch drawn from another person describing them always shows them as much warmer and beautiful person. This raises questions like: Why are we so critical of ourselves? and What causes us to see ourselves as so much worse than another person would see? How does media play a role in this? If it is a negative one how can it be diminished? In my personal opinion, I think that this is because we have to live with ourselves our whole lives and we are always finding little imperfections about ourselves. Also, I think it could be a little bit of an audience effect. We generally say that we aren't that great around other people in fear of being judged or just because they are around and it is the popular thing to do. It could also be learned helplessness. A few of the people in the video talked about physical traits that they had and they would say "my mother always told me I had (insert negative trait)" or "my sister always told me I had (negative trait)". Because they heard it so much, it just became a normal response to agree with what these people had to say. What do you guys think? Why are we so critical of ourselves? What is the role of the media here? Any relevant terms you can apply to this situation? Any other thoughts?
Are you a good driver?
Ever since I started driving, I quickly started thinking that I was a pretty good driver. After learning about Self Serving Bias, I applied it to my thoughts on not only my driving, but everyone's driving. If you ask yourself, "Am I a good driver?" you would probably say yes. Nobody would want to believe they are a bad driver. However, you would blame a many other drivers as being bad drivers. So what makes you better than every other driver on the road? Is everyone equally mediocre at driving, but their self serving bias influences them believe that they are above average ? Or is the average driver good?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)