Thursday, May 19, 2016
Dehumanization
In chapter thirteen of the Lucifer Effect, many examples of dehumanization are shown. Some include the Rape of Nanking, the Nazi genocide of Jews, slavery, and when the Japanese brutally massacred Chinese civilians. In all of these situations, the victims were viewed as animals such as insects, cockroaches, and rats. Sergeant Mejia stated, "You just sort of try to block out the fact that they are human beings and view them as enemies." I believe that dehumanization can relate to situated identity. Do you think that anyone can become like the people who were able to kill innocent civilians, Jews, and slaves? I believe that if put in the correct situation, anyone can be vulnerable to act out of character due to their surrounding environment. What are your thoughts on this topic?
Interactions with a Psychopath
Today in class we briefly talked about the San Bernardino shooting that happened a few months ago and how the couple who committed the shooting were labeled as psychopaths because they committed this mass shooting. Many people disagreed because of the fact that everyone that knew them said that they were nice, normal people. Psychopaths can fake being a good person for a while, but being their neighbor or close friends you'll soon be able to see that something is off. This made me think about my neighbors and how I would have no idea if they were psychopaths because I rarely talk to them. It brings up an important point, how many people do you surpass everyday that could be psychopaths and you wouldn't know because you never talk to them. Thoughts?
Right or Wrong?
Right or Wrong?
I've experienced this all my life. What is right and wrong? By the role models of your parents, every child should know the difference between right or wrong at an early age. According to NPR, children at ages 3-4 should be able to "recognize certain behaviors - such as hitting - as wrong, even when so one is watching" (Smetana). There's no such thing as right or wrong, more like what someone feels is the best thing to do. There is no machine or technology that measures right from wrong. This would be hard for a 16 year old teen who never understood the difference. For example, let's say a 12 year old was taken out of a household filled with his/her mother lying, cheating, and stealing. The child knows that the actions are wrong. Once they reach 16, he/she begins demonstrating similar tendencies learned from /his mother. Let's say the 16 year old commits a crime for the first time and uses lying and stealing. If the teen is pressed with charges, would it be their fault? Or would it be the parent's fault? Who should be the one to take true responsibility? And what if charges are pressed but the teen can't determine what is right or wrong? Is it pointless to punish them, when they don't understand what is right or wrong? Let me know what you think.
Wednesday, May 18, 2016
The media and stress
We have been talking a lot about pressure and stress among students these last weeks. I realized I liked this topic and wanted to learn more about it, so I started doing some research. Lately, I’ve been feeling more stressed than I was before. I’m sure it’s because the end of the school year is coming and we have final tests in two weeks. But, could it also be Availability Cascade? I feel like since everyone talks about how stressed kids from the bay area are, some students hear and read in the media so much about it that they accept it as a reality. I noticed this because in Spain (where I’m from) we also have a lot of pressure to get good grades and succeed, but the extreme amount of stress in students is not a big issue as it is here. Back there I have the same expectations as I do here, but since I read that the level of stress among kids here is really high, I applied it to myself and accepted it as a reality. What do you guys think about this? Do you think that the media is making us believe that we are more stressed than we actually are?
The Lucifer Effect: Palo Alto Highschool
In chapter 12 of The Lucifer Effect there was an experiment held by a history teacher named Ron Jones who wanted his class to experience the inhumanity of the Holocaust by simulating it. The experiment took place in five days and did not go as the teachers and school official planed. The simulation started off slow in only one history class where rules had to be obeyed everything the teacher says without question, they also made a rule where students could only answer questions in three words or less making it harder for the more intelligent students to show their dominance in the class. The class even made their own solute and slogan just as Hitler did. At this point things started to get more intense, students hung banners throughout the school to recruit new members, authoritarian members of the class started to kick the more intelligent students out of the class abusing them as they left, and soon enough the so called "Third Wave" class experiment became a school wide movement. Soon after a Third Wave Youth rally was announced, more than two hundred students who were so called the "true believers" waited for the announcement of the new presidential election for the third wave leader and soon they saw who they were all admiring and following, the former German Nazi leader Hitler. Out of all the experiments in The Lucifer Effect I personally find this the most disturbing, seeing how students like us were so easily manipulated to follow a former Nazi dictator sends a message that we shouldn't let our own desires overcome us. This shows us how as single powerful authority can turn us against our morals and beliefs and lead us astray,
The Lucifer Effect: Nurses
In chapter twelve, an experiment was performed with nurses and their patients. Twenty-two nurses received a phone call from a staff doctor. The doctor ordered these nurses to give the patients twenty milligrams of the drug "Astrogen", even though five milligrams was the norm, and ten was considered the maximum dose. When this scenario was explained to twelve nurses, ten insisted they would disobey the doctor's orders. However, during the real experiment, twenty-one of the twenty-two nurses listened to the doctor and were ready to give their patient twenty milligrams even though the bottle clearly stated against that. This experiment is a great example of how people respond to authority. I believe this relates to the strip search experiment. In both situations, people do things they know are not right just because a person possessing power told them to. What are your thoughts on this experiment?
The Lucifer Effect: Jim Jones
In The Lucifer Effect, we read about a man named Jim Jones who was able to influence more than 900 of his followers to either kill their friends and family or commit suicide in masses. What was interesting about this was the fact that this man was able to have power over so many people who had minds of their own, but still bent to his will. How was this man able to have such a huge influence on these peoples' lives?
What allows someone to have a wide range of control over a large amount of people at once? It is said that his methods of inducing obedience in his followers included warping reality, created lies, false analogies and ideas that appealed to the people whom he was talking to in his speeches. Additionally, there were reports of his followers referring to Jones as "Dad", which would mean that he had made a sense of family between him and his followers, contributing to their obedience factor to him. Jones' ability to influence people through twisting words and creating false senses of reality definitely ensured that his followers would abide to his will, similar to Adolf Hitler and the Nazi party. What really allows people to have full control over large masses of others?
What allows someone to have a wide range of control over a large amount of people at once? It is said that his methods of inducing obedience in his followers included warping reality, created lies, false analogies and ideas that appealed to the people whom he was talking to in his speeches. Additionally, there were reports of his followers referring to Jones as "Dad", which would mean that he had made a sense of family between him and his followers, contributing to their obedience factor to him. Jones' ability to influence people through twisting words and creating false senses of reality definitely ensured that his followers would abide to his will, similar to Adolf Hitler and the Nazi party. What really allows people to have full control over large masses of others?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)