Showing posts with label Leena Janmohamed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Leena Janmohamed. Show all posts

Thursday, January 28, 2016

Sleep Paralysis vs Lucid Dreaming

While we were in class discussing lucid dreaming, I had the question: what's the difference between sleep paralysis and lucid dreaming? People who have had a sleep paralysis experience say it is extremely scary and disorienting.   But, in the TEDx talk we watched in class, the speaker discussed lucid dreaming as being something pleasant and empowering.  There's obviously a difference between the two, but what exactly is it?

Sleep paralysis is where a person, during the act of falling asleep or waking up, temporarily experience an inability to move or speak.  This transition stage goes hand in hand with muscle weakness and terrifying hallucinations.  Relating to what we talked about in class-- sleep paralysis is speculated to result from disrupted REM sleep.  The body activated a temporary muscle weakness to stop you from immediately acting on your dreams.  When sleep paralysis occurs when a person is falling asleep, what happens is their mind is still awake while their body is shut down for REM sleep.  Think of it like being trapped in a dead body.  When it occurs as a person is waking up, they are aware before the REM cycle ends.  What makes sleep paralysis so scary is the vivid visions that accompany it.  Most of the time, individuals sense a menacing figure (an intruder of some sort) and on top that, are paralyzed and feel extremely vulnerable.  The figure is automatically assumed to be "evil" because during sleep paralysis, pathways in the brain become over-excited, and the mind perceives every stimuli as a threat in an act of protection.  Another possibility of a vision is an unearthly being attempting to suffocate the individual.  This happens because during sleep paralysis, the person is unable to breath voluntarily-- most because of characteristics of REM sleep that limit normal breathing.  This inability to take a deep breath is perceived as some sort of demon pressing down on the individual's chest or trying to strangle them.  

So, basically, lucid dreaming is when you are in control of your dream and have power over the outcome and content.  Sleep paralysis is when you are caught in your dream and loose control completely.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Psychodynamic Psychology: Valid?

Psychodynamic psychology, a then newer form of human analysis developed by Freud, reasons that choices and actions made by a person are not actually an active decision by the person.  Rather, these choices come from an urge or desire that rests deeper in our mind-- a part of our brain inaccessible to us.  These desires show themselves to us only in our dreams, mannerisms, and forms of expression (including art and writing).  If this thinking is to be believed, then it is reasonable to assume that we do not have entire control over our actions, reactions, and choices.  This essentially means that free will is an illusion, and no matter what control we think we have, our primitive instincts ultimately override our conscious decisions.  All of our choices are pre-determined by the simplistic urges of our unconscious mind.  This is effectively illustrated in our body's inability to commit certain actions that will inevitably cause pain.  However, if we believe this theory, then conditioning a person to behave in a different manner than what is dictated by their instincts is theoretically impossible.  If we are fundamentally unable to control our choices and are unaware of our true motives, how are we able to change the way we make decisions or react to a certain situation? If Freudian psychology is to be believed, than behaviourism is impossible.

Further, critics of psychodynamic psychology stress that any evidence gathered by a psychologist practicing psychodynamic psychology is completely biased.  There is no proof of an ulterior motive behind a person's decision-- especially if the person themself are unaware of this motive.  Also, this form of psychology assumes that reasonless behaviour does not exist, and that there is always a hidden meaning behind decisions; meaning dictated by those desires that we are not aware of.

So, think about this: 
According to psychodynamic psychology, you do not have entire control over the decisions you make, and any conscious choices or actions you make can be overridden by primitive desires and true motives you don't know you have.  Essentially, there is "someone" "living" in your mind, making your decisions for you, and determining the way you will react in certain situations.  How's that for free will?