Although numerous people have blogged about the Stanford Prison experiment and Milgram's Electronic box experiment, I have not yet seen a blog about Kitty's stabbing and the experiment that followed. Kitty was stabbed in the night under a lamp post, and let out terrible screams while no one came to her rescue. As the documentary mentioned, many of the viewers watching this documentary think to themselves, "I would have been the one to go help" or "I would've been the hero." But in reality, a lot of us will act just as the bystanders did the night of Kitty's murder. The reason for this is that we all think that someone else will do the job for us, so that we don't have to bother getting out our flashlights, walking down the stairs, and checking to see if everything is ok under that light pole. So, because of the bystander effect, no one saved Kitty and she died that night.
I thought that this story was particularly interesting because it demonstrated how reliant we really are on other people. There were over 60 people who heard Kitty's screams that night, some who ignored them and some who admitted that they figured someone else would just go check to see what was happening. Later, this concept was being analyzed in an experiment to test whether a person would go help another if one was having a seizure. When there was only one person aware that the actor was having a seizure, he or she would immediately go to help. However, if there were multiple people in the room, the people would look around at each other before going to help. This experiment further proved the bystander effect-- when others are around, people are more likely to stand by while something is happening rather than step up and help.
Both of these examples demonstrate the bystander effect, but neither answers why this is the case. Is it because people are embarrassed to go help incase that they might be wrong about a situation? Is it because people are too lazy to help? But why would this be the case if they would jump right up if they were the only person around? In my opinion, I think that many people are scared to jump in because they may be blamed for something going wrong, when really they were just trying to help. This makes sense for Kitty's case because if someone had gone down to help Kitty and she still died, maybe the person helping would have been blamed for not doing a good enough job of protecting her. However, this reasoning does not work for all cases. Do you guys have any ideas for why the bystander effect occurs in such threatening situations?
Tuesday, April 5, 2016
Thursday, March 31, 2016
The Milgram Obedience Study and the Stanford Prison Experiment
If we look at the Milgram Obedience Study and the Stanford Prison Experiment, we can see some similarities, both in the results and their purpose. Both experiments originally were designed to test how people behaved as inferiors, with the Milgram experiment testing how they reacted to being urged on by a superior, and the Stanford Prison Experiment was originally designed to test how people reacted to being powerless. Further, both tests showed that, when gently urged by a higher authority, be it Milgram or the Stanford professors, people took the authority's instruction very seriously, even to the point of dangerous overkill. In the Milgram experiment, the subjects were willing to subject victims to high levels of voltage, much in the same way the Stanford Prison Experiment's subjects made life miserable for the "detainees". If we look at these combined factors of obedience to authority and a willingness to conform to a role, we can see the roots of what happened in Abu Ghraib. According to the documentary, the supervisors gave vague instructions to "soften the prisoners up", which the soldiers accepted as an order due to the obedience shown in Milgram's test, and became violent torturers due because of their conformity to their new role, as shown in the Stanford experiment. If we look at the world's events through the lens of these two events, we can see the root of many of the world's events.
Wednesday, March 30, 2016
Laramie
Laramie, Wyoming is located in Southern Wyoming, about 2 hours from Denver and an hour from the state capital of Cheyenne. Laramie is also the location of University of Wyoming, home of 14,000 students. Visiting from California was defiantly a culture shock. I am looking at attending college at the university and really enjoyed the university. It was a small town feel, built around University of Wyoming. It is amazing what an university can do for a community, bringing in people and revenue. The small town feel had lots of shops and dining to check out, and a country feel. If you are looking for a big city with lots of people and clubs and big concerts this is not the place. The campus was beautiful with lots of renovations and new constructions. Wyoming is the only 4 year public university in the entire state, thus they get all the state funds for the university. The university is also a division 1 sports school, who competes in the Mountain West Conference vs schools like San Diego State, Boise State and University of Nevada Reno. All in all this was a lovely place that I think would be a cool place to attend college.
Tuesday, March 29, 2016
Behind Situational Bias
Behind Situational Bias
Let's get right into it.
Situational Bias. What is it? It the tendency to attribute a behavior, seen often in an external event, and less to a person's inter characteristics. All over the world, this concept has been studied to determine how it influences a person's actions in a given situation. Through several articles and reports, I have found that situational bias is highly seen with a group of people. This study has shown various examples in the change of human behavior. For instance, if your teacher asks you or one of your classmates to answer a question, and no one raises their hand, very few will feel obligated to raise their hand. Due to the fact that no one raises their hand, a group demonstrating the same reaction to a situation highly influences the behavior of others. Does this have to do with a person's incapability of specific character traits, or the environment one is in that influences their decisions?
Monday, March 28, 2016
Stanley Milgram's experiment and my personal example
Stanley Milgram, a well known psychologist, conducted a very thought provoking experiment in 1962 at Yale University. He brought in well educated men in to their lab and they were asked, by the "authority," to shock "learners" when they got questions wrong. These men being tested were called the "teachers." They were told that they were part of an experiment studying learning, but really their behavior was the thing being tested. They were supervised by the "authority" dressed in a white lab coat, who would tell them to proceed shocking the "learners." The learners were only actors, but they were instructed to scream, try to get the "teacher" to stop shocking them, and also stop responding as if unconscious when the "voltage" got really high. Every time a "learner" would get a question wrong, the "teacher" would go up in voltage. The voltages went up to 450 volts, 66% of them actually continued until they reached the most dangerous voltage. Some wanted to stop, but the "authority" would tell them to proceed and most did.
I have heard about this experiment before, but today in class we watched a more in depth documentary on this experiment. Although, a disturbing experiment it reflects the tendency of humans to comply with the so called "authority." This experiment tests just how far obedience will go. The man who conducted this experiment, Stanley Milgram, explained this experiment's connection from what was seen in the Holocaust. Most of the people who aided in the perpetration of the Holocaust were seemingly normal people. But, Milgram wondered, how could normal people commit such acts that they knew were wrong?
I think that this tendency to do what the "authority" says is okay to do, is seen in many cases. If an "authority" tells them it is okay to do something, they automatically assume they can do it because the "authority" has taken responsibility. In that way I think this experiment shows diffusion of responsibility. They do not feel like they are in charge, so they continue to do it. I see this in a lot more innocent ways in my life. An example, one time I was at a party with my family. I was having fun talking to some of my mom's friends. She had briefly left to have a conversation in the kitchen, but she left her phone on the table. Her friends wanted me to take a picture of them and post it on my mom's instagram, without her permission. I was skeptical because I knew my mom would not want me to do this, but because they kept telling me that they would take responsibility if she was mad I did it. It all worked out in the end, but I would have never done that to my mom if I did not feel like I could point my finger at them and say, "They made me do it!" Do you guys have any personal examples of when you have seen this same human tendency in your life? Do you think diffusion of responsibility is the key problem here?
I have heard about this experiment before, but today in class we watched a more in depth documentary on this experiment. Although, a disturbing experiment it reflects the tendency of humans to comply with the so called "authority." This experiment tests just how far obedience will go. The man who conducted this experiment, Stanley Milgram, explained this experiment's connection from what was seen in the Holocaust. Most of the people who aided in the perpetration of the Holocaust were seemingly normal people. But, Milgram wondered, how could normal people commit such acts that they knew were wrong?
I think that this tendency to do what the "authority" says is okay to do, is seen in many cases. If an "authority" tells them it is okay to do something, they automatically assume they can do it because the "authority" has taken responsibility. In that way I think this experiment shows diffusion of responsibility. They do not feel like they are in charge, so they continue to do it. I see this in a lot more innocent ways in my life. An example, one time I was at a party with my family. I was having fun talking to some of my mom's friends. She had briefly left to have a conversation in the kitchen, but she left her phone on the table. Her friends wanted me to take a picture of them and post it on my mom's instagram, without her permission. I was skeptical because I knew my mom would not want me to do this, but because they kept telling me that they would take responsibility if she was mad I did it. It all worked out in the end, but I would have never done that to my mom if I did not feel like I could point my finger at them and say, "They made me do it!" Do you guys have any personal examples of when you have seen this same human tendency in your life? Do you think diffusion of responsibility is the key problem here?
Friday, March 25, 2016
Intervention: Gina
Gina's heroin abuse was largely due to the negative treatment she received from her mother. This was a good example of psychological projection where her mother projected her negative feelings about her hard life onto her daughter through beatings. Gina used heroin as an escape from reality so she no longer had to feel the pain. It was interesting to see that after such a short, yet emotional conversation in which her mother admitted her wrongs and apologized, Gina was willing to accept treatment for her problems. It seems like her mother never did actively try to go out and get Gina the help that she needed. Rather, she just kept blaming Gina over and over again through negative reinforcement. This only furthered the problem and worsened their relationship. So, when she realized that her mother really did wish the best for her, she accepted without hesitation. Overall, this intervention highlighted the impact that "showing love" and "positive reinforcement" can have on an a troubled person rather than playing the blame game.
60 Days In
There is a new TV show on A&E called 60 Days In. It is about 7 innocent everyday people like us who volunteer to go spend 60 days in the local county jail. Everyone has their own reason of why they signed up for this. The guards and the prisoners both are unaware these normal people are planted in the jail. They are each given a fake name and a cover story so the inmates and guards don't get curious. They are also brought in at different times as well, making it as believable as possible. A lot of the volunteers for this show want to see reform in the prison system, and feel it is not an effective system. One former marine describes the food as better than the military. This man is saying we feed our prisoners better than our military. Another woman comments how she has never been so lazy in her life, just laying around in jail. Why do we just let these people sit in a room and have free time and get somewhat decent meals. There is a strong feeling among these people that instead of letting people just sit in jail and waste time, lets make them of value in the world. Lets have them do something productive with their time and try to make them better as people to learn and grow. Very interesting and hits hard, especially because some of us are 18, and others will be in a few years. Once you're 18, you could end up in jail with some of these men and women. It was a major eye opener to me and to be smart.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
